Tuesday, June 28, 2016

"Losing Hold"

Backdated, archival post

[link to original on tumblr]

---&---


I don't think my recording really does this justice.

I can't change the tone of the organ presets on my keyboard (an-other reason why getting a Nord - with physical drawbars! - would be such an advantage), so the organ tone doesn't match that well.

The bass during the repeated part at the end (which I played only part of because I don't know the whole mellotron part) is more complex than what I played, but I haven't figured out that part perfectly yet.  This is actually a lot more than I thought I was going to do when I said I figured out some of the bass part.  Mostly I was talking about the staccato notes and the long phrases that replace them later (one of them extends two whole octaves, up to the twelfth fret G), but then I kept learning more of it.

In Deep is the only Argent album I have as a record, so I can refer to the record sleeve for publication data (I'm not always too confident that what I find on the internet is right).  The record credits "Losing Hold" to Argent and White:


According to the Zombie Heaven liner notes, Argent and White wrote separately but starting with "Imagine the Swan" they shared the writing credit.  Because of this ambiguity, I sometimes wonder if a song is an Argent or White song.  Obviously, I'm not sure of this, but I would guess that "Losing Hold" is a Rod Argent song because it has some of his characteristic three-note chromatic phrases in the bass part.  The staccato notes at the beginning are A G# G, over which are played A major, C# minor, and G major; the chromatic phrase starting from the root note of the first chord in the sequence is a very Argentian progression.  Later, during the repeated section at the end, there's a three-note chromatic phrase of C B Bb.

The chord progression has some resemblance to that of "Hung up on a Dream" too.  They both have a section where each chord is only one note different from the previous.  In "Hung up on a Dream" it's G major (G, B, D) to E minor (E, G, B) to C major (C, E, G).  Here, there's a section of F major (F, A, C) to A minor (A, C, E) to C major (C, E, G) to E minor (E, G, B) to G major (G, B, D).  This sort of incremental progression is more visually obvious on a keyboard instrument, which makes me think it's Argent's song.