Sunday, May 27, 2018

"Without Her"

Last week, I was thinking about some Harry Nilsson songs, and I realized a couple things about "Without Her" (I think I'm actually more familiar with the Neil MacArthur version than Nilsson's). 

First, just a simple thing: "And I rise" in the first verse is sung to an ascending melody (D E F), musically representing that "ris[ing]."

More significant is the vocal melody during this section:
We burst a pretty balloon, took us to the moon
Such a beautiful thing, but it's ended now
And it sounds like a lie
I said I'd rather die than be without her
The melody rises (almost a full octave: from F# to F) from the beginning up until "but it's ended" and then falls from "ended now" onwards.  The descent skips around a bit (the lowest note is a B), but generally it goes from F to C.  The ascending melody musically portrays the happiness of going "to the moon" and the "beautiful thing," and the descending melody the sadness of "it's ended now" and the singer/speaker's change in mood.